top of page

I panicked about “looking like a man.”

5 days ago
7 min read
I faced my fear of being ugly, but didn’t realize there was a DEEPER fear. #TransparentTuesday
I faced my fear of being ugly, but didn’t realize there was a DEEPER fear. #TransparentTuesday

Hi friend!


Nine and a half years ago, right after turning thirty, I buzzed my head. 



I had always wanted to do it, at least once in my life, just to see how it felt. 


Every time I saw a woman with a buzzed head, I felt a powerful zing of envy and inspiration deep in my gut. 


I was in awe of the courage and fortitude she must have had to break such an important social rule for women, and of her willingness to reject feminine beauty ideals. I wanted to be that kind of person, and so I became one. 


I didn’t buzz my head because I thought it would look good on me, or because I thought I could “pull it off.” In fact, exactly the opposite! 


I was actually pretty positive that doing so would make me a lot less attractive—at least according to conventional beauty ideals and the male gaze—and I was genuinely worried that my head was too small and my features were too soft for it to “work.”


But that was the whole point. 


I wanted to be the kind of person who prioritized courage over comfort, and authentic self-expression over validation or acceptance. I wanted to reveal and address any insecurities that my hair might have been inadvertently hiding, about my face or head or body, and I wanted to challenge people’s perceptions and ideas about how we’re “supposed to look.”


I knew it would make me less attractive, acceptable, and desirable to others, and I wanted to conquer the anxiety that that still brought up for me, as a person who had been socialized to equate my attractiveness with my value and worth. 


The experience was incredibly healing and valuable for me as a person, and it deeply informed my work on body neutrality. I’m still very proud of myself when I look back at the photos! 


What's interesting to me now when I look back, however, is that I was very conscious I was breaking the rules for looking “conventionally attractive,” and that a buzzed head would negatively impact my hotness level and social status. But I was much less conscious about how that decision betrayed a social expectation that is much deeper and much more important than “looking good.” 


And because I wasn’t thinking about it, I ended up totally shocked by how threatening people found this particular bit of rule-breaking, myself included!


What I know now, but didn’t know then, is that the most sacred of all sacred cows in our culture is this one: that a person must be immediately recognizable as either a girl or a boy; a woman or a man. 


I was prepared to break the rule of looking attractive, but I wasn’t prepared to break the rule of looking like—and being immediately interpreted by others as—a woman. 


It has to be said that, at this point in time, I hadn’t yet come across the language to describe how I experience my own gender, or come to identify as “non-binary” the way I do now. So I was still identifying as a cisgender woman, and the idea that someone might accidentally mistake me for a boy or man still filled me with shame. 


Put another way, I was still beholden to my internalized and unexamined patriarchal gender conditioning, and I still held a lot of false and oppressive beliefs about how a person is “supposed to” express and display their gender to others. 


As a lifelong self-objectifier on a body neutrality mission, I was prepared to face and metabolize the discomfort of experiencing a drastic decrease in male attention, approval, validation, and desire, and everything that came with it.


  • I was prepared to see how much less warm, friendly, polite, helpful, and kind men would be to me without hair. 

  • I was prepared for people to gawk, and to ask if I was a lesbian. 

  • I was prepared for conventionally attractive women to gush about how they “could never be that brave,” and give me other backhanded compliments. 

  • I was prepared for people to say things that it was “such a shame,” and that I’d look “so much prettier” with longer hair, as if my choice was robbing them of an experience of looking upon beauty that they felt entitled to. 


I knew other people wouldn’t understand or like my decision, and I was fully prepared to deal with their disapproval, displeasure, criticism, and overall weirdness. 


What I wasn’t prepared for was how uncomfortable it would make me to lose my most obvious visual indicator of gender.



Without hair, I became self-conscious that my gender was no longer immediately obvious to others at a glance, and I had complicated feelings about being misgendered or misinterpreted. 


Like most people, my social conditioning about gender had taught me that at best, it would be insulting and embarrassing to be mistaken for a guy. (For example, if someone at the grocery store called me “sir” before actually looking at me, and then immediately corrected themselves.) 


But if someone legitimately couldn’t “tell,” or they came to the wrong conclusion about my gender even after looking at me for a while, or they described me as “manly” or “masculine”? 


According to my internalized social conditioning, that would have been deeply and overwhelmingly humiliating. 


It’s not uncommon for experiences of being miscategorized or misgendered in this way to feel so mortifying and shame-inducing that they’re understood as traumatic, in fact—I’ve had clients for whom a comment about looking “manly” was the first trigger to a lifetime of struggling with body image!


I wasn’t consciously aware of how my gender conditioning was impacting me at the time, but I still felt pressure to present myself in such a way that people could quickly and easily identify me as a “woman.” 


And without my hair screaming “it’s a girl!” to everyone, I suddenly found myself anxious and insecure that people might not be able to tell.


So without even thinking about it, I found myself buying new stuff and styling myself in new ways that would unambiguously communicate my gender to others at a glance. 


I started decorating myself in the trappings of femininity that had previously repelled me—maxi dressed, colorful flowerprints, long dangly earrings—without even fully understanding why. 



I was like a mother with a newborn, popping a pink bow on the baby’s head to make sure everyone “could tell.”


I wasn’t consciously aware that my sudden changes in stylistic “taste” was actually just a coping mechanism, designed to avoid the fear and shame that my social conditioning had taught me to associate with a failure to adequately communicate my gender to others visually. 


It just happened. And then, as my hair grew back out again, I found myself mysteriously no longer wanting to wear those things, until the dresses were all donated and the earrings were covered in dust. 


I’m telling you this story because it’s a perfect example of how our social conditioning about gender plays a huge role in how we understand ourselves and move through the world, without us even being consciously aware of it!


Had I known then what I know now, I would have taken the opportunity to further challenge and divest from my internalized gender conditioning, in order to reclaim my autonomy and liberation even further. (Because as I would find out later only through exploring my own queerness, I am not authentically attached to being seen as feminine, or as a woman.)


But that’s the thing: when we’re still operating on our automatic programming and unexamined social conditioning, we’re not really free, and we’re not really our authentic selves. 


We’ll never be our fullest, happiest, most actualized or expansive selves if we’re still unconsciously trying to conform to any social expectation or ideal, or trying to fit ourselves into any predetermined box. 


It just so happens that under patriarchy, the first and most restrictive “box” we learn to fit ourselves into is gender. 


In my experience, understanding and dismantling gender conditioning tends to be one of the “last” pieces of the puzzle for a lot of people. 


Because this conditioning is so difficult to see, it tends to be something people do only after they’ve already done a good amount of therapy, coaching, healing, or self-development work—after quite a bit of re-education about systems of oppression, and after they’ve made a good amount of progress challenging and divesting from other false and oppressive social frameworks, expectations and ideals.


And while I do think a lot of that work may actually have to come first, I get why a lot of folks end up feeling frustrated and stuck. They sense that there’s still something holding them back, or like there is still too wide of a gap between what they consciously believe, and how they actually feel and behave day to day. 


I believe addressing and neutralizing what I’m calling “gender conditioning issues” is the missing link between the inner work you’ve already done, and the place you want to actually arrive. 


(It was for me, and it has been for so many of my clients.)


This work is the link between knowing your worth, and feeling worthy. 

It’s the bridge between supporting women’s empowerment, and actually standing in your power. 

It’s the difference between being a feminist, and actually being liberated.  


This is why I’m offering 5 free coaching sessions (one each per person, for new clients) to anyone who wants to learn more about this topic, or explore their own relationship to gender performance. 


Want to start exploring how your own gender conditioning might be standing in the way of your most authentic, confident, and expansive life?? I would love to help you!


Hit reply (if you got sent this via email), or send me a message here to take advantage of one of these free coaching sessions!


To liberation,

Jessi


 
 
 

Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
bottom of page